The Return


Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey wasn't quite the mythological epic I had hoped for but it did reignite my interest in ancient Greece and one film that had certainly benefitted from that blockbuster was 2024's The Return. This was the modestly budgeted drama which focuses on Odysseus as he lands in Ithaca many years later after he left for war but much has changed. 

Much like The Odyssey, director Uberto Pasolini does away with any of Homer's fantastical elements and roots the film firmly in reality so we are without any mention of giants, the cyclops or the sirens, which conveniently suits the film's smaller scale but will disappoint anyone in search of a more faithful adaptation. But we do get is a more considerately paced drama with great performances from Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche in the leading roles that I would say trump Matt Damon and Anne Hathaway with their American accents. 


However, the air of TV drama does hang around The Return whenever Fiennes or Binoche aren't on screen with its smaller sense of scale due to the limited production design and weaker supporting cast. Pasolini's pacing might also be too slow for many causing the film to drag at times but it is all worth it to see Fiennes on top form as the drama gradually comes together. It is in those moments where I would say Pasolini tops Nolan's adaptation but it is hard to justify the price of entry given the near two hour running time.

The Return is a sturdy companion piece to The Odyssey, book and film, but it will leave anyone not familiar with the overall story out in the cold. I do hope we see an adaptation not afraid to go all in with the fantastical elements and a budget to do the story justice but The Return is still a decent drama that survives on the strength of its leads even if I can only recommend it to die hard fans of Homer's work. 

Comments

Popular Posts